Casual vs permanent jobs in aged care: Workers tell us what they want

Casual vs permanent jobs in aged care: Workers tell us what they want

Should he accept a permanent role, or remain with his employer’s contract arrangement, which allowed them to charge a higher hourly rate?

The question is an important one for aged care staff at a time when their skills are in high demand, and for the industry, which is grappling with staff shortages, concerns about financial sustainability and quality care.

COVID-19 highlighted the dismal working conditions and insecure nature of many aged care roles, and the potentially devastating effects when aged care workers are forced to work multiple jobs between homes just to make ends meet.

The royal commission also identified contracting as a “significant trend” in recent years that was not conducive to building a “skilled, career-based, stable and engaged workforce” that was capable of delivering “high quality aged care”. 

The commissioners recommended that from 1 January 2022, the regulator should keep an eye on levels of contractor employment, and record the extent to which aged care providers rely on independent contractors.

The Aged Care Workforce Taskforce also identified casualisation of the workforce as one of the industry’s key challenges.

And perhaps, most importantly, it seems aged care workers themselves would prefer the certainty and security that comes with permanent employment, not casual jobs.

The post in HelloCare’s support group on Facebook attracted over 60 comments, and almost all of them encouraged the original poster to accept the offer of permanent work.

“Permanent also means that you will have a minimum amount of guaranteed hours at the workplace, whereas casual they may fluctuate your shifts (38 hours one week and then 10 hours the next week). 

“It’s more financially stable to have a permanent part time or full time job,” one commenter wrote.

Several members of the group also noted that if the original poster ever wanted to take out a loan or obtain a mortgage, it would be almost essential to have permanent employment. 

A few aged care workers said they prefer the flexibility and higher hourly rates of casual work.

“It’s not worth it unless you are wanting to secure a home loan to provide a regular income, as the pay rate is a big drop,” one commenter said. 

“If you’re happy to take holidays and sick days without pay, then stay casual.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. The ideology of remaining as a casual employee in the aged care industry is understandable. Workers receive both the casual loading and shift penalties which can add several dollars per hour to their pay rate. It is also the reason why a significant proportion of workers choose to work for two Not For Profit providers on a part time basis, as they can receive the benefit of two lots of salary packaging. Now we also see workers undertaking the same types of work for NDIS recipients, but being paid up to $7 per hour more. What is not understandable, is that the majority of us know that there are insufficient people to support residential aged care, home care, CHSP and NDIS recipients, and that the governments remain oblivious to the work force crisis that is now upon us.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

‘We eat with our eyes’: getting food right in aged care

  It’s a common situation we see all too often in aged care facilities: a resident doesn’t want to eat their meal. The person may not be able to communicate why they don’t want to eat, they may not like the meal, or the food may be too difficult for them to eat. They may... Read More

Waiting list for home care packages reaches 108,000

More than 108,000 Australians remained on the waiting list for their appropriate level of home care as of 31 March 2018, including 88,000 with high care needs, according to new data released by the Department of Health. There were 104,000 on the waiting list for home care as of 31 December 2017, indicating an increase... Read More

The importance of the ‘human element’ when training aged care workers

In being so task-oriented, what happens is that the carers can “forget” what is really the most important part of their work - the resident. Read More
Advertisement