May 14, 2019

Daughters could not find help in mother’s final hours

The royal commission has heard the care delivered to a 70-year-old woman in the final weeks of her life was “inadequate” and described by her daughter as “a disgrace”.

The commission heard the woman, who was referred to as DE during the proceedings, was struggling to breathe when her daughters came to visit her one evening.

“It sounded like there was an engine of a truck or a lawnmower engine running,” said one of the woman’s daughters, who was referred to as DI.

“It was this loud rumbling that was so disconcerting and scary I think as soon as my sister heard this we ran.”

Daughters frantically searched for help

The sisters found their mother alone, and began “frantically” searching for staff to help them.

It took them “at least” half an hour to find someone to attend to their mother, and when staff did arrive they were of little help.

They said there was “no communication” with staff who had poor English, and “seemed to be very busy and run off their feet”.

The daughters were “in a state of panic”, and called a palliative care nurse who had seen their mother. Though the nurse was not available, another nurse at Greenwich Hospital tried to help them.

“So we were kind of holding on to this phone call with this woman, because it was the only person that would speak to us. And she was wonderful. And thank God we could get hold of her, but there was only so much she could do, being not in the room and… not the person taking care of Mum on that night,” DI said.

The nursing home called the after hours doctor, who, when he finally arrived, stayed for less than one minute.

“He said, ‘This isn’t really my area of expertise, and then walked out’,” DI said.

“Evening of mum’s passing was a farce”

DE’s other daughter, DJ, said, “The whole evening of Mum’ s passing was a farce and, honestly, an absolute disgrace.

“There was not enough staff. The staff who were there did not seem to know what was going on and we were in the dark the entire time,” DJ said.

“No compassion”

A few weeks after DE died, DI and DJ made formal complaints to Bupa and the Aged Care Complaints Commission.

“After Mum’ s death my sister and I raised our concerns with Bupa Willoughby and tried to get some answers about what happened and why things went so wrong. In all of my dealings with Bupa Willoughby during this time I felt like they were trying to dismiss our concerns. I felt like they were not listening to what I had to say and did not want to admit fault,” DJ said.

“For an organisation that exists to care for people, it seemed like they had no compassion for us at all.”

Missing testimonies

In a statement to the royal commission, Maureen Berry, clinical service improvement director of Bupa Aged Care Australia, said the staff involved in DE’s case no longer worked for the organisation.

However, she had to concede that four registered nurses who cared for DE did remain working for the company. Ms Berry’s error meant these nurses were not asked to provide evidence to the commission.

Bupa’s care was “appropriate”, says director

Ms Berry told the royal commission the clinical care DE received was “appropriate”, although she admitted that, “There are times when care provision wasn’t as prompt as it could have been or perhaps explained as well as it could have been or documented as well as it could have been.”

Ms Berry also agreed that DE’s nutrition and hydration needs were not adequately looked after, that she was not properly supervised at meal times, and that the absence of her hearing aids and glasses would have made it difficult for her to communicate.

Ms Berry agreed that there was poor communication between Bupa and DE’s family and that DE’s pain was not adequately assessed.

“Quality of care was inadequate”: Complaints Commission

DI and DJ took their complaint to the Aged Care Complaints Commission, and an investigation was carried out.

The Commission’s report on the incident said, “The quality of care delivered to DE at the care home was inadequate, primarily due to deficiencies in clinical leadership and supervision.”

Inconsistencies between care plans and assessments were identified, such as for pressure area care and the presence of an air mattress.

“Bupa has identified the potential risk to care delivery from a lack of clinical leadership and supervision when both the general manager and regional director have no clinical background and we are addressing this issue at an organisational level,” Bupa responded.

Image: Witness DI during the royal commission hearings.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. Reading this upsets me greatly. The thought of having to put a vulnerable person into a facility to be cared for by ‘professionals’ scares me. This is an all too common story, people left to die slowly and painfully because facilities would rather turn a profit that provide adequate care, proper medical attention and pain relief for the residents. I’d rather keep my mum at home and care for her myself than trust these bloody facilities to keep her safe.

  2. I noticed that Bupa dismissed the care staff but the 4 Clinical RN,S remained employed at Bupa,this is typical sack the and blame the care staff instead off those whom were actually in charge off this lovely ladies clinical issues.I have seen this happen too many times in my 25 years off caring,and yes there is not enough training both in class and on site so you get these new care staff coming through and a lot do not have a clue when they are put on the floor it is a sad sad situation.

  3. Bupa needs to kicked out , they should be never be aloud to have nursing homes . Profits come 1st than care and that is the same of a lot of the owned profit nursing homes . They are all too greedy and burning their best workers due to poor ratios , then employ less experienced workers who have no passion in aged care .Ken Wyatt knows these problems and has ignored as all . He should not be the aged care minister.


Grass roots advocates join forces in call for Aged Care Royal Commission

A coalition of grass roots aged care advocates representing thousands of concerned citizens across Australia have joined forces to call for a Royal Commission into residential Aged Care. Action of Elderly Abuse Now group spokesperson Charli Maree Darragh, whose mother was murdered in a residential aged care facility in 2014, said the ABC 7.30 report’s... Read More

5 Ways to Assess Pain that Every Aged Care Worker Should Know

Monitoring pain in aged care residents is crucial to ensure their comfort and quality of life. To improve the management of pain and to create pain vigilant aged care facilities it has been proposed that pain is considered the fifth vital sign, after temperature, pulse, blood pressure and respiration rate. Pain needs to be assessed... Read More

Fears residents will be neglected as aged care home proposes cuts to kitchen staff hours

A Tasmanian aged care provider plans to cut more than 200 hours from its kitchen staff across four homes. “Staff were in tears saying this is just going to mean residents are going to be neglected,” said the union. Read More