Apr 13, 2022

“It’s chemical restraint”: 1 in 5 aged care residents given antipsychotic medication

Chemical restraint aged care

The data has been gathered as part of the National Aged Care Mandatory Quality Indicator program, which has included medication management since 1 July 2021. 

The latest data reflects the period 1 July 2021 to 30 September 2021. For the survey, nearly 170,000 residents were assessed at more than 2,400 aged care homes. More than one in five – 21.6% – of residents received antipsychotic medication, while only about one in 10 – 11.6% – received antipsychotics with a psychosis diagnosis.

Juantia Breen, Affiliate Associate Professor with the University of Tasmania, who also provides training to aged care homes on medication use on behalf of the Aged Care Quality and Safety Commission, told HelloCare research she did seven years ago found 22% of residents in their sample of 150 homes were taking antipsychotics. 

The more recent data indicates an identical rate of antipsychotic use today in over 2,000 homes. 

“I would have expected the rate of use to be lower given new legislation, prescribing restrictions, focussed attention on this issue and this new quality indicator,” Breen said. 

Breen said the reasons rates remain high are “complex”. 

“It’s a combination of low rates of staff, not enough training and support given to staff to manage behaviours of dementia by using other strategies, but also issues with the organisational culture in many homes where GPs and staff reach for sedating medicines as the first resort rather than the last resort. 

“I also see many homes not referring people to old age mental health services and dementia support,” instead preferring to manage complex behaviours in-house.

Breen said another reason rates remain high is that a lot of older people come into residential aged care on the medication and stay on it for “much longer periods than the guidelines and the legislation recommends”.

It’s chemical restraint

The fact that high numbers are still being given antipsychotics without a psychosis diagnosis tells Breen the medications are being used “for reasons other than what they are intended for – often to manage behaviour of people with dementia, but also of people with intellectual disability and of people who may have no diagnosis but may be agitated or distressed”. 

Aged care homes can benchmark against the data

Breen said the quality indicators are a “good start” in helping to reduce the use of antipsychotics in aged care, but aged care homes need to be more proactive about their approach to the drugs.

“Hopefully homes will now gauge and benchmark their use.”

She added, “If antipsychotics are used at rates at 22% or more, the home needs to ask why?

“What other behavioural support mechanisms do they employ? The most important questions are how long has this resident been taking this medication? Is it working? Does it have side effects and can we reduce the dose with a view to ceasing? 

“Involving relatives and decision makers in these decisions is not only good practice but now legally and ethically required,” she pointed out.

Royal commission prompted reforms around chemical restraint

The Royal Commission into Aged Care Quality and Safety heard of “excessive use … of physical or chemical restraints, which rob our elders of their dignity and autonomy, and which can result in serious physical and psychological harm, increased health complications and … death.”

 They noted that deficiencies in the regulation of chemical and physical restraint in aged care are a “significant human rights issue” in Australia.

The regulation of chemical restraint was tightened from 1 July 2021. From that date, when medication was used as chemical restraint, the prescriber had to obtain consent. In the common situation where the older person is not able to give consent, consent will need to come from the “restrictive practices substitute decision maker”. 

The new legislation also requires chemical restraint only to be used where there is clear documentation of behaviour that may cause harm or distress to the older person, that there is a risk of harm to the person or to another person, and that there has been an assessment of this behaviour by a medical or nurse practitioner who has day-to-day knowledge of the older person or by a behaviour support specialist. 

There also needs to be documentation of alternative strategies that have been tried, and that what is being proposed is the least restrictive alternative.

However, the latest QI data shows the rates of psychotropic use remain high.

Providers should be held accountable

Human Rights Watch has issued a statement suggesting the high rate of antipsychotic medication in aged care is related to inadequate staffing and training, factors that have been exacerbated by the pandemic.

Elaine Pearson, Australia Director with Human Rights Watch, said, “The Australian government should ensure that policies for older people respect their dignity and human rights.”

They said providers should be dealt tougher penalties when they misuse the medications.

“The Australian government should ensure aged care providers that wrongly administer medication to restrain older people are held accountable for their actions.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. When will we get it that unlawful restrictive practices -that is chemical, physical or environmental restraint without lawful consent, or where there is no imminent harm to the person or to others, is a breach of our fundamental legal rights as Australians. The criminal penalties in the ACT are 5 years, in Queensland 3 years and Victoria 10 years. Sooner or later someone will do some time in prison for this. Only then will there be real change in practice in aged care – and in the disability sector as well.

    1. It’s shocking to see these stats, I witnessed instances during Mum’s 15 month stay in an Aged Care Facility. I feel for Residents with Dementia and for those without an advocate

  2. I agree, staff undertrained, more resources needed. Dysfunctional in some ways –

    I did thank the staff by including them in His death notice.

    A 24 x 7 specialised nurse trained for aged care is paramount.

    My father was given antipsychotic drugs
    Around 2 weeks (I’m guessing) before his death. (For calling out – he was anxious – didn’t have confidence in the facility).
    After given to him he was found unresponsive (in a near unconscious state). And very cold. the doctor came on a Saturday for a consultation- prognosis this is normal part of ageing.
    After waking they sat him up in bed. He had a bite to eat and a small amount of fluid.
    He became not able to walk at all.
    His breathing was laboured.
    Then he lost his ability to swallow and talk.
    He then laid in bed with a tube for spittle.
    Which bruised and cracked his mouth.
    He refused the pipe. Couldn’t eat or drink.
    (At a guess) It took about 3 days without eating or drinking to die.
    On his death certificate the doctor put that he had Covid. I received a notification 5 days previous that he was negative. Their wasn’t a sign on his door. Also cause of death Renal failure.

    I would have liked a chart for observations and medication given – surely that should be mandatory.

    I hope this helped.

    1. It is the body’s Natural response to palliating to not require food and fluid . That’s why we apply oral cares and why families should accept a morphine pump so their loved ones can slip away peacefully without pain . It’s sad to do cares on someone every 4 hours that causes them pain and discomfort.

  3. No surprises here. Chemical and physical restraint are rampant in Aged ‘Care’. Better informed consent would stop this practice at point of sale. A proper explanation of risks, benefits and alternatives should be carried out with the resident and their Carer. I don’t think that there are many children out there who would want to see their grandmother robbed of dignity and sedated into oblivion just so a nursing home can save on staffing.

  4. Anti psychotics can be used to settle someone who otherwise doesn’t settle at all at night . There are other residents to think of too . A chemical restraint sounds terrible but much better than a physical one . Some injure themselves or others . There’s a lot of different reasons . Check the Behaviour charts .

  5. All I hear is criticism and blame. This problem requires a solution. That solution is more resources. Those resources include staff, qualified staff, and more specialists in non pharmacological interventions. Counseling services, education, and more resources. The impacts of ageing are multifaceted and to ameliorate care requires clinical leadership and governance. Better models of care can do this. Just look for the solutions and take action.

  6. This sounds like facilities are giving antipsychotic medications to consumers without theirs or NOK consent. Some NOK ask for their loved one to comfortable and agitation free. Its not the facility that prescribes the medication they only give it on doctors orders. No one wants to sedate or restrict their family member but they do want them to not be tortured by the cruel effects of dementia.
    I guess its always easier to blame the caregiver.

Banner Banner
Advertisement
Banner Banner
Advertisement

How can we fix this? 1 in 6 experienced elder abuse in the past year

COVID-19 has led to an increase in elder abuse, with WHO (World Health Organisation) data showing two in three aged care staff confessing they have committed abuse in the past year. HelloCare looks into this report on World Elder Abuse Awareness Day (June 15).  Read More

Your bed probably isn’t as clean as you think – a microbiologist explains

There’s nothing quite like crawling into bed, wrapping up in your blankets, and nestling your head into your pillow. But before you get too comfortable, you might want to know that your bed isn’t all that dissimilar to a petri dish. Read More

When operations subtly cause our powers of thinking to deteriorate: Postoperative Cognitive Dysfunction

Have you known of someone who had an operation, and family and friends say afterwards, “They haven’t been quite the same since”? Sometimes surgery can subtly impact mental abilities. In particular, after surgery some patients report problems with memory, attention, multitasking, and concentration. This condition has been dubbed ‘postoperative cognitive dysfunction’ (POCD), and it can... Read More
Banner Banner
Advertisement