Nov 01, 2019

“If The Aged Care Minister Is ‘Shocked’ He Should Resign Immediately.”

The Royal Commission into Aged Care Quality and Safety’s Interim Report was released yesterday afternoon, and if the conversations in the weeks leading up to the release of this report were anything to go by – very few people were shocked by what they read.

The Interim Report, entitled Neglect, covers much of the work of Commissioners Richard Tracey AM, RFD, QC, and Lynelle Briggs AO through to September 2019, and was both candid and scathing in its assessment of the aged care sector and those that control it. 

The Government, The Department of Health, Aged Care Quality and Safety Commission, aged care providers and their peak bodies were all called into question regarding their role in the current state of the aged care system – a system that the report believes “diminishes Australia as a nation.”

While there has already been a flood of opinions regarding the findings of the interim report, there are very few who boast a resume that encompasses as many facets of the aged care sector as Dr. Rodney Jilek. 

Dr. Jilek started his aged care journey as a nurse in the early 90’s and by 1997 Dr. Jilek was already a Director of Nursing (DON) and managing a high care nursing home with over 90 beds.

Over the next 20 years, Dr. Jilek worked in a number of corporate and advisory roles within the aged care industry and was actually a Clinical Advisor for the Aged Care Quality & Compliance/Department of Health and Aging. 

These days, Dr. Jilek is the Principal Advisor at Aged Care Consulting and Advisory Services, where he provides advice and works alongside aged care providers who have failed aged care accreditation, which gives him a unique insight into the problems being faced by the sector.

Problems – that according to Dr. Jilek, we were already well aware of.

“There is absolutely nothing in the report that comes as a surprise at all and everyone in positions of power were well aware for years – government knew, regulatory bodies knew, peak bodies knew and senior members of the sector knew. It has been swept under the carpet for decades,” said Dr. Jilek.

“Failed providers continue to fail over and over again, failed executives become consultants and advisors and are embraced by the sector peak bodies, sanctions are meaningless and all the issues just get hidden away and ignored. The system allows it all.”

Airwaves and inboxes were flooded this morning with opinions from all corners of the aged care sector, but Aged Care Minister Richard Colbeck and Health Minister Greg Hunt have both declared themselves ‘unavailable’ to answer questions. 

In a press conference in Canberra yesterday, Mr. Colbeck declared that he was ‘shocked’ by the extent of the interim report’s findings, which is rather unusual when you consider that the majority of seasoned aged care figures are all well aware of the problems.

“If he is genuinely shocked by this he should resign immediately,” said Dr. Jilek.

“The government, Department of Health and The Commission all knew. They have spent the last two decades trying to ignore it and bury it as deep as they could by gagging anyone who wants to speak out.

“The Department is full of people who have no interest or experience in aged care and they are a large part of the problem,” he said.

Mr. Colebeck would not commit to an increase of aged care funding in yesterday’s press conference, but PM Scott Morrison has promised that Australia will see more aged care funding before Christmas on 3AW this morning.

Although a funding increase is welcome news for the majority of the sector, the problems that stem from deriving profits from care were touched upon at numerous points throughout the report.

The report went as far as to say that the current aged care system was “designed around transactions, not relationships or care,” and that structural changes that made it easier for profit-driven providers to enter the market and accompanied by a ‘lighter-touch’ accreditation approach. 

The report also noted that the current aged care system has been framed around the idea of a ‘market’ for aged care services, which is evidenced by the use of phrases like ‘clients’ and ‘consumers’.

Concluding that older people are not in a position to negotiate prices, services or standards and the idea that aged care is an effective consumer-driven market is a myth – as there is little choice in aged care. 

“The government’s policies of sector consolidation and a market-driven sector have turned older Australians into a commodity to be traded and exploited in the quest for profits and have fundamentally encouraged this disaster to happen,” said Dr. Jilek.

“While I have said for years that the funding available is not enough to provide the highest quality care and meet everyone’s expectations, the basics such as respect, privacy, and dignity are free and we haven’t even managed to do that consistently across the sector.

The report was also highly critical of the current regulatory process that was put in place to ensure the safety and quality of aged care services, labelling it “unfit for purpose” and incapable of adequately deterring poor practices.

The report also claimed that large portions of accreditation reports conducted by the Aged Care Quality and Safety Commission were generated by computer-assisted text that simply spammed positive words and lacked the human element of determining quality.

The regulatory regime was also deemed to “do little to encourage better practice beyond a minimum standard,” and action against those who failed to deliver the minimum standard of care was deemed ineffective. 

The regulatory bodies have been, and continue to be, completely ineffective and fail older Australians on a daily basis and inconsistency and dodgy interpretations of the legislation by senior departmental delegates rob older Australians of their rights,” said Dr. Jilek.

“Everyone involved in aged care in this country should be profoundly embarrassed today.” 

It was refreshing to read a report that was candid enough to express the same level of bewilderment and anger being felt by millions of Australians who have been failed by the aged care system.

But it’s deflating that many of the same people and departments who are complicit in this systematic failure will go unpunished for the sub-standard care outcomes experienced by older Australians.

The Australian aged care sector has been a cesspool for far too long, and in order to create real change, we might just have to look at draining the swamp first. 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. Wow!! Jacob I love you. From someone who has worked in the Aged Care system as an AIN for 9 years You and a few others actually see the problems. It is all to do with the big guys and girls profiting from our elderly. My instinct was shock and sadness when my facility listed their company up for shareholders. Who in their right mind would see the old and sick up for profit sharing?? It just seems so morally wrong. Fingers crossed that any subsidies the government hand out from now on will be scrutinized and the money spent for our dear elderly on better quality staff and better wages and conditions. This may well be a great and positive opening to attract more Australians into the sector!

  2. Spot on – when Minister Colbeck started in the job he should have read the Senate April 2019 Effectiveness of the Aged Care Quality Assessment and accreditation framework Final Senate Report. He would have passed out!

  3. I have had first hand experience with this lack of care, patience and understanding of the Aged care section of our country. My mum, who passed away four months ago, was a victim of abuse. bullying and lack of understanding. I was unable to care for mum as the awful disease of Alzhiemers took hold. I did care for her for 9 years previously. We had our laughs and tears but never once did I treat her like an inferior person. She cared for me when I was ill as a child and now it was my turn to care for her. When she was admitted into full time care in the Aged Care section of our local hospital I was very unsure and nervous about how mum would react. It was a very hard adjustment and mum did not like it. On a couple of occasions I went to see her and she was upset about the way certain nurses spoke to her. One of the times I went in she told me she had cried all night and was afraid. I immediately went to the Nurse in Charge, who asked me if I wanted to put it in writing, to which I said yes. To make a long story a bit shorter the nurse was reprimanded. The nurse came a few days later and apologised and said she was a bit short tempered that day. I told her that she had upset mum and that she had been crying. I don’t know if it sank in or not. I don’t know if anything else happened to the nurse but she was still in the ward and still ‘dealing’ with the aged residents. That was just one incident, there have been a few more that we have had to see senior staff about. It is like you are the enemy and they put their guard up as soon as they see us coming. No empathy, understanding or care for that matter. I certainly hope things change dramatically in the not to distant future. It is too late for my mum.

  4. So sorry your dear mum was not treated with the respect and dignity she deserved. Until our polititicians and aged care advocates stop using the term “burden” refering to the no’s of elderly needing aged care now and into the near future, it will be inbedded in our society’s psyche. The more you hear the term the more people see our elderly as a problem. I can only hope by the time they become fragile and dependent on others that the Aged Care issues will be a thing of the past.

  5. What a poor excuse from a Minister of the Crown, who is renumerated exceptional well by the tax payers of Australia. Do new Ministers not receive a ‘hand-over’ from departing Ministers and their staff?


The key ingredient for seniors living with diabetes

Food is one of the key ingredients for managing conditions like diabetes and malnutrition. For seniors, having easy access to ready-made, low GI meal options can help to ensure that you remain living at home for longer. Read More

Do Nurses Working in Hospitals Look Down on Aged Care Nurses?

What you do on a daily basis, eventually becomes part of who you are as a person. And while personal aspirations can vary, there’s no denying the fact that having a fulfilling career is an achievement that lends itself to personal happiness and feeling valued. While there are a number of career paths that seem... Read More

Background paper dampens expectations ahead of royal commission’s interim report

  The royal commission has released its latest background paper, a comprehensive summary of the many reports and inquiries of the aged care sector that have been completed over the last twenty years.  The paper casts a long, question-marked shadow over the highly anticipated interim report, which is due out later this week, that will outline... Read More