Jul 08, 2020

Elderly man mentally unfit to stand trial for wife’s murder

 

A 74-year-old man has been declared mentally unfit to face trial for the stabbing death of his wife at their Merrylands home in Sydney’s western suburbs.

Father-of-three, Vincenzo Coluccio allegedly stabbed his wife Elia Coluccio while she slept before washing the knife and driving himself to the Merrylands police station where he told officers that “something terrible” happened.

Mr Coluccio had been in custody for more than five months following the night of his 63-year-old wife’s death, but he will not face trial for her murder after being declared mentally unfit by a judge who examined multiple expert medical reports.

Reports claim that one psychologist concluded that Mr Coluccio had a substantial mental impairment and mild intellectual disability, while another psychologist believed that Mr Coluccio was unsure about whether he was was was dead or alive.

It is believed that Mr. Coluccio was also fearful that his wife was “setting him up” and it is alleged that he also made claims that he believed that his wife had been cheating on him and that his children were mocking him.

“I am not satisfied that Mr Coluccio is capable of following the trial, understanding the evidence or instructing his lawyers,” said NSW Supreme Court Justice Robert Allan Hulme.

“I am also not satisfied that he can comprehend the defences open to him.”

Mr Coluccio listened to the judgment through an interpreter but remained silent throughout.

Although declared unfit for trial, Mr Coluccio will remain in custody until further order by the Mental health Review Tribunal.

 

Photo credit – iStock – SonerCdem

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

Moving into a retirement home after a lifetime in the family home

After 48 years in the same house, Sarah is preparing to move into a retirement home following the loss of her husband. Storyteller Michael Preston recounts her final walk through the rooms and garden that hold a lifetime of family memories, reflecting on the life built within its walls. Read More

Dignity in the details: Why bathing is never just bathing, in aged care

In this moving reflection, storyteller Michael Preston shares Rosie’s deeply personal memories of bathing, dignity and trust in aged care. A powerful reminder that washing is never just a task. It is intimacy, vulnerability and humanity in its most fragile form. Read More

‘I was going to walk again’: An aged care resident’s fight for mobility

Bed-bound and reliant on a hoist, Sue Brennan was told walking again might never happen. Sixteen months later, she walked out under her own power. Her recovery is a reminder of what persistence and structured rehabilitation can achieve. Read More
Advertisement