Jan 20, 2020

Preventing suicide in nursing homes is possible: three ways to make a start

Briony Murphy, Monash University and Joseph Ibrahim, Monash University

Suicide among nursing home residents is a major concern. Between 2000 and 2013, around 140 Australian nursing home residents took their own lives.

This issue has been hidden for too long, and met with minimal efforts targeted at prevention.

We consulted with experts and stakeholders in aged care, geriatric medicine, old age psychiatry, suicide prevention and public policy to develop 11 recommendations for the prevention of suicide among nursing home residents.

In our recently published study, we put forward three of these as the highest priorities for implementation: expanding suicide prevention frameworks to include aged care residents, aligning nursing home life with community living, and improving residents’ access to mental heath services.

The scope of the problem

Risk factors for suicide among nursing home residents include having diagnosed depression, declining physical health, and being within the first 12 months of residency. This suggests adjustment – to the onset of health problems or to life in a nursing home – can be problematic.

More than half of nursing home residents suffer symptoms of depression. This is compared to 10-15% of adults of the same age living in the community.

Notably, young people in nursing homes (64 years and younger) are three times more likely to take their own life than their counterparts aged 65 and over.

Although the reported number of suicides each year in nursing homes (around ten) is relatively small, deaths from suicide represent only the “tip of the iceberg” of self-harm and suicidal behaviour in nursing homes. Research has shown one in every seven residents exhibits self harming behaviours on a weekly basis, such as cutting, hitting, or eating foreign objects.


Expanding suicide prevention frameworks

The first key recommendation is expanding existing state and national suicide prevention frameworks to include older adults and those living in institutional settings with targeted prevention strategies.

In practical terms, this would offer care providers clearer guidelines to recognise and address suicidal ideation and behaviour in nursing home residents, taking into account this group’s unique set of risk factors.

Making nursing homes less like institutions

The second recommendation is aligning nursing home life with community living to make nursing homes a place where most people would be happy to live.

This requires addressing the physical presence of the nursing home within our community. As one research participant commented:

[…] many care residences isolate residents from the community. Most residences are fortress-like, closed, inward-looking buildings with few public views to the outside.

Evidence points to better quality of life among residents of smaller cottage style or cluster communal residences, compared to standard Australian models of residential aged care.

We can also look to examples of innovative nursing home design outside of Australia.

Another aspect of this recommendation is addressing the atmosphere and organisational culture within the nursing home.

Organisational culture differs between facilities, but a common thread is staff being more task-oriented, or focused on ticking boxes, than person-centred in their care approach. This is due to time pressures and is notoriously difficult to change.

Improving the mood in nursing homes would involve emphasising person-centred care, and encouraging residents to be social and involved in the wider community.

Ultimately, we need to address negative community attitudes towards transitioning into a nursing home and challenge the prevailing societal view death is preferable to living in residential aged care.

Better access to mental health services

The third recommendation is improving residents’ access to mental health services, including allied health and medical specialists.

This will be essential to manage the high prevalence of depression, anxiety and other mental health issues, as well as to support residents with their progressive decline in health and independence.

We’ve already seen steps to change the Medicare system to ensure residents have access to medical and psychological treatments for mental health disorders, with additional funding announced in the 2018-19 federal budget.

Further steps might include routine mental health assessments alongside physical health check ups for all residents. This would see mental health issues identified early and treatment plans put in place.

We also need to better recognise the traumatic impact of the nursing home environment, where more than one-quarter of residents die each year. One participant in our research noted:

The effect of a dying friend down the corridor is often put in the too hard basket.

Being more open about death and dying should prompt better support for residents, families and staff.


Next steps

These recommendations provide the first substantive foundation for suicide prevention strategies in nursing homes in Australia. If no action is taken, older people, their families, staff and the community will continue to suffer.

The next step requires action from government, regulators, professional organisations and the aged care sector to support implementation and evaluation of these recommendations.

We don’t need to wait for the Royal Commission into Aged Care Quality and Safety to conclude before beginning this important work.

If this article has raised issues for you, or if you’re concerned about someone you know, call Lifeline on 13 11 14.

Briony Murphy, Research fellow, Monash University and Joseph Ibrahim, Professor, Health Law and Ageing Research Unit, Department of Forensic Medicine, Monash University

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. Thanks for the article. This is a very difficult area that one is forced to tread very carefully into.

    I have for some time been concerned about our tendency to see all suicides in terms of psychiatric pathology. Whilst we may want to prevent suicides in aged care, to the person who is thinking of taking their own life it may be a rational response to a variety of irreversible losses. The loss of a spouse, a family home, of physical independence, legal and financial autonomy, the loss of the long term pet, these, and many more, losses typically manifest as a cause of (or a result of) the person entering residential care.

    Yes, our society does not value old people. It does not value people who do not work. Yes, aged care facilities are designed to maximise occupancy rather than a home like environment. But even if it was designed around the concept of ‘the home’ still it is not a home. [After all ‘home’ is not an architectural space – it is an emotional space]. These are cultural obstacles that are not going to change any time soon. Society, for better or worse, has ‘more pressing’ demands on its time and energy. Cultural change takes decades.

    All I am saying is that we ought to be wary of viewing all suicides as evidence of psychiatric pathology. Some are about the person taking charge of whatever control they have left over their own lives.

  2. We live in a world so afraid of death and in denial of it. Suicide is not tragic when you get to the age where you cant even take yourself to the toilet. Life in a bed being kept by nurses is not a life and suicide in these circumstances is not tragic but should be a part of life. I have worked in an aged care home. Everyone should at leat for two weeks
    I certainly will be suiciding when my time comes, no way in the world will I want to be in an aged care home. All dignity is lost! Walk into the ocean with a back pack and have a party before you go. We are not meant to languish away in nursing homes. It is completely unnatural and we need to learn to embrace death which is not death it is just going to the next phase


The Changing World of Families

Once upon a time extended families lived together. The “maiden aunt” helped out, looking after babies and young children, often preparing delicious meals – which was a tremendous asset to any family. Mum and dad could go to work, enjoy their sports and social activities knowing the children and in fact the whole household was... Read More

Music in Aged Care: Bonding for Residents and Students

There is often a misconception that having a “generation gap” means we cannot connect with people who are from a different time to us – whether they be younger or older. However, there are many benefits from encouraging intergenerational experiences with the elderly. It allows the older person some value and purpose in the interaction... Read More

Wound Awareness Week 2020: tackling an unnoticed crisis

The hidden epidemic of chronic wounds impacts the health, wellbeing, and finances of many Australians. Treatment and care for chronic wounds this year will consume over $3 billion from the health and aged care budgets. For individuals, the average out of pocket cost can be around $4,000 a year. Read More
Exit mobile version