Jan 19, 2017

The Stigma of Working in Aged Care

I feel it has to be said.

I’m sure I’m not the only nurse to work in aged care that has felt this way. Perhaps this is something I have felt and observed as I continued to work in aged care and hospitals at the same time.

When I made the decision to leave my job working in the hospital, I still recall my colleagues saying “why do you want to work in aged care?”, “isn’t that something you do when you’re close to retirement or return to work after having children?”

Well not for me, and I hope by opening up the conversation and talking about the stigma that exists, that people can start to see another side to working in aged care that extends beyond cleaning dentures and bed pans.

Working in aged care, or should I say doing something that involves surrounding myself with elderly people, is where I wanted to be. It made me happy. I felt, and I still do, that I could make a difference in their lives.

I’m still trying to work out what exactly it that creates a stigma not only in the healthcare system but within the general public. Some of the possible thoughts I’ve considered over the years are:

1. Is it not glamorous or fast paced enough?

Like other areas of healthcare. Is this stigma preventing our youth as seeing this as a viable career path or aspire to work in one day? How do we change these preconceived views and make it a more attractive option to work in?

The television shows ER portrayed nurses and doctors working in a fast paced work environment where lives were in the balance and much of the job was life or death.

While, contrastingly, aged care generally gets portrayed differently; more often than not these films are comedies where the carer/nurses accidentally ends up in the job of caring for quirky personalities. Which probably adds to the thoughts around what a perceived ‘typical nursing home’ is like to work in.

2. Is working as a nurse in aged care perceived as “lower skilled role”?

Does a perceived ‘lower acuity’ of residents in aged care facilities automatically assume a “lower skilled” nurse? I suspect people working in rehabilitation at some stage feel a similar element of stigma.

Working in aged care isn’t just about taking care of old people who can’t simply take care of themselves – many people I have cared for are palliative, advanced dementia, or chronic diseases and can be very fragile and very sick.

The majority of residents I’ve cared for do want to be transferred to hospital if they become unwell and therefore making sure their wishes are upheld means a nurses clinical skills need to be sound.

A resident that deteriorates rapidly requires a quick thinking nurse to assess the situation and determine exactly what the resident needs. Often with little backup. There is no MET call. There is no luxury of calling the Local Medical Officer or getting the specialist in as soon as possible. The options available are calling the ambulance, phoning the GP and hoping the answer or assessing is the resident is stable enough to stay in the nursing home.

Sure, nurses in aged care may not need to undertake as many clinical tasks as hospital nurses but it comes close. A nurse in aged care is in charge of making clinical decisions at any one time for 60 to 130 residents.

Other clinical task that are similar to what ward nurses would be expected to do and often more. Sure there are no doubt less Intravenous Therapies (IV medication). But everything else is: inserting catheters, medications,
drugs of dependence, insulin, In some nursing homes intravenous medications, complex wounds and palliative care.

3. Is it due to the way our elderly are perceived in society?

They talk about the “elderly as disposable”, where there is an image that the elderly are a low-value demographic costing the taxpayer millions in health care, particularly as people live longer and diseases like dementia become increasingly common. Do we as society overall not value our older generation?

Being an aged care nurse can be just as demanding as the nurses you seen in hospital ERs, it’s just a different kind of demand. By no means is the job easier or more relaxed.

I’m certain I’m not the only nurse that has felt this at some point in their career.

I’d love to hear from others if this is something that you have felt. Likewise to other nurses working in other areas or even people not in the industry share your thoughts on this…

Image: Call the Midwife – Nurse Jenny Lee leaves a “traditional” nursing job to help the elderly

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. I to work in aged care and I love it. I have mostly however from other nurses get very negative comments. My days are very full and sometimes with up to 30 residenents to be responsible for ( in the evenings) , I have come to accept that I love my job the relationships I build with residents and their families, sometimes we are the only family they have. I have not lost skills but found so many more. It is hard and we are expected to do so much with the little time I have but spending time with these wonderful people in their ending days is a privilege for me and they make me laugh , and cry but mostly love at their antics, stories and wisdom. I often be with them at the end of their days which is often peaceful and with no regrets. I work hard but the rewards are great . So please instead of the negativity why not be positive and thank us for the role we play….. just as you I am registered, I am continually learning and I to have wonderful skills.

  2. Leanda Ada, what a lovely letter and you should be very proud of yourself. The elderly do have good stories to tell and so deserve to be loved and cared for. It is a very hard job and can be sad also. I care for my husband and have an elderly mother in care, she will be 110 in a month.She really is not with us any more but we love her dearly and the nurses and carers are so good to her. I think the carers do a great job and I think that the nursing homes should have more staff. It makes me very angry that greedy people who own the homes can`t put the residents before money.

Banner Banner
Banner Banner

Report Shows Lack Of Aged Care Staffing Linked to Increased Hospitalisation

A new report that was released by participants of a NSW Aged Care Roundtable has uncovered a number of systematic failures including a lack of staff are increasing the likelihood of poor care outcomes for aged care residents. Calls for mandated staff ratios have grown deafening over the last 12-months and the fact that this... Read More

Spiritual Care: Finding Purpose at the End of Life

While the world continues to change, the state of senior care does as well. Those in their later stages of life can feel forgotten. An increasing percentage of older people are now being admitted into facilities at older ages, when their physical and mental abilities seem to be in rapid decline. Experiencing the sudden break... Read More

Community should support greater transparency in nursing home staffing

Community support for a Bill which would see aged care providers forced to publicly disclose the number of staff they roster on to care for elderly nursing home residents, is being strongly encouraged by the country’s largest union, the Australian Nursing and Midwifery Federation (ANMF). ANMF Federal Secretary Annie Butler described the Aged Care Amendment... Read More
Banner Banner