Jan 25, 2018

“I reported my concerns, and subsequently I was not offered anymore shifts”

This was a letter submitted to HelloCare by an aged care worker and advocate. These views are a reflection of her own and we believe it is important to give everyone a platform to share their opinion. 

I have been involved in healthcare for over 20 years, here and in the UK – first as a Healthcare Assistant/Personal Care Worker/Support Worker, and now as an Trainer & Assessor, teaching adults how to be Personal Care Workers/Support Workers.

I struggle internally with my current position because I know what my students are heading into – an overworked, underpaid, undervalued industry.

When I first started in this sector we were using bed rails and putting clients with Dementia in straight jackets, now chemical restraints are used instead with lap belts and Princess Chairs.  Not all places use these cruel and archaic forms of restraint, but even the better ones still have room for improvement, such as, design of the environment, education, higher staff ratios and technological advances.

In Residential Care in particular, staff cut corners – they don’t wash their hands or use hoist machines because there is no time to do the basic things, let alone spend quality time with people.

There is a total lack of privacy and respect, staff don’t always knock on doors and clinical staff will give medication when clients are sitting on the toilet. Also, there are still some facilities that don’t give residents their own rooms, and some don’t even have ensuites. This means residents have to be whisked down corridors to have a shower or use the toilet. Such places use communal all in one soap/shampoo/conditioner, and don’t provide clinical gloves for their staff – but food handling or such like instead.

I have witnessed broken blinds and no curtains between the beds. I have heard a man screaming out for eggs, but was told he couldn’t have any because it was not Monday. I reported my concerns to the Enrolled Nurse on duty, who did not seem to care – reporting the mantra of ‘it’s not Monday.’  I asked to speak with the Registered Nurse, but I was told there wasn’t one on duty, so I asked to speak to a more senior staff member, but I was told that they weren’t available either.

Another time a resident reported to me that they had been hit by a staff member. I told the Registered Nurse on duty, but they seemingly did nothing. Currently under the legislation that’s all I need to do, and the Registered Nurse does not need to do more if the person has Dementia (I believe this resident did have Dementia). However, without Mandatory Reporting of abuse and a proper investigation, how will we ever know the truth?

I have also been asked to fudge documentation for funding purposes, with residents not being allowed physical interventions or resources to enable them to stay on a higher care package. Plus I was paid under the award wage.

I reported these all the above concerns, and subsequently I was not offered anymore shifts.

My family and I had concerns about the Residential Aged Care Facility where my Nana was living a few years ago, so when the Aged Care Quality Agency visited I asked a relative to pass on my concerns, as I was unable to due to other commitments. Unfortunately my relative was fobbed off, and was asked to provide this information to the Complaints Team. I thought my concerns would have been of relevance. I question why these two agencies aren’t mandated to work together?

In the past when I was young and naive, I saw horrific pressure injuries, which I attended to instead of a nurse. Unfortunately, the industry still relies on young uneducated women and/or migrants, along with others who have limited employability options. This needs to change.

Recently I went to the Best Practice conference here in SA, and they had a panel at the end with a case study discussing the possibility of Elder Abuse. Everyone on the panel, except for one person, thought the case study was probably abuse and detailed what they would do about it. The person who did not think that the case study was abuse, was a person who was currently working for the Aged Care Quality Agency.

I wish I could say I was shocked – I was not. Even the one ordinary older citizen (not a specialist in aged care) thought it was abuse. Following the panel discussion I challenged the person from the Aged Care Quality Agency, which made them rethink their position and change their mind. I was pleased that this happened, but it should not take a room full of people to make this happen, being that this was a specialist in their field who should know what abuse is.

Maybe, this is because the Aged Care Quality Agency is currently a paper tiger who do nothing. Visits are usually announced and the surprise ones get tipped off. Organisations only have to have paperwork in order to pass, which is very easy to do or fudge. Plus, when noncompliance is discovered organisations don’t receive harsh enough penalties.

Because of this I, along with two other women have come together and formed Aged Care Reform to advocate for change in this sector.

With an upcoming state election in SA, we feel this a good opportunity to highlight these crucial issues, and would like to invite you to attend our rally on Saturday 17 February 2018 at Parliament House, 11:30am1:30pm:

If you can contribute in any way please get in touch.

Remember – we are all ageing.

What do you have to say? Comment, share and like below.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. Good to hear people speaking out. How we care about older people shows so much about society – and sadly, at the moment, we could do so much better.

  2. I have work in aged care for many years and seen a lot. cares given out meds and not just webs pack S8 and if you say no the boss says there the door, cares not use lifter or use them by themselves, o yes I lost jobs for being outspoken time the hole age care change it a sad hard place to work in

  3. You have hit the nail on the head I have witnessed in 8 YEARS THINGS THAT NEED CHANGING.My mother was in a NSW care facility & everything & more that you covered I witnessed & when I or my family complained we were targeted but I persisted. the Age Care system needs CHANGING & the Gov.Depts need a good shake up .Thank you for your stand I wish I could attend but in a different state & health matters prevent this .Please do not give up .God Bless You & Your Friends. I thank God that you are a trainer & assessor.

  4. Which is exactly why the Gillard government took steps to support ‘in-home care’ ….which initiative, rather than being developed and refined, and expanded, when this right-wing federal government came into governance, they axed mercilessly, preferring all the horrors you mention to properly caring for the elderly with dignity and love, and respect


Grey Armband Day to Unite Local Communities in Fight Against Elder Abuse

Thousands of sporting teams, players, club supporters and community organisation members will take to the fields, courts, sidelines and stadiums of Australia next year as part of a new national grass roots community initiative aiming to help prevent the abuse, neglect and exploitation of older Australians. In June 2018, the inaugural national Grey Armband Day... Read More

Where should the blame lie when assaults occur in aged care?

A few weeks ago, we published an article titled, ‘Rough treatment in aged care is not assault, says magistrate: Four Corners’. The article was viewed by more than 40,000 readers through our social media channels, and received hundreds of comments. Among those to respond was a retired expert in his field who wishes to remain anonymous, but his thoughts on the... Read More

Coping as a carer

  Being a carer for a loved one is hard. In this episode of Grey Matters, Tracey and Ben discuss tips to help carers stay the distance while looking after themselves as well. To listen to the podcast – press the play button below. Key points discussed: How to be a great carer without falling... Read More